Forum Topic
Engineering
MemberOvomorphJune 14, 2012********THIS THREAD IS A WORK IN PROGRESS********
These are truncated interpretations of forum members "plot holes" or unaswered questions along with answers and explainations from various members...
1)[u]Is sacrificing one of their kind really the best way they have to create life on earth in the beginning of the film?[/u]
2)[u]Why would Weyland spend so much money to fund a mission with no hard evidence that Shaw and Holloway's theories are correct?[/u]
[b]He's a multi-quadrillionaire or mega-rich for that matter. Money is no object and immortality is his only desire.[/b]
3)[u]Why is Shaw portrayed as a Christian believer yet she forms a hypothesis that contradicts Christian beliefs?[/u]
[b]In the film someone says that her beliefs are incorrect because the Engineers created humans. She answers with "Yes, but who made them?" She has her own beliefs that are obviously based in Christianity but every Christian does not believe or worship in the same way.[/b]
4)[u]Why was Weyland playing like he was dead and hiding in cryo besides plot reasons?[/u]
[b]He was in cryo to preserve the short time he had to live. As far as why he hid it from the crew perhaps he's an eccentric multi-quadrillionaire who likes to mess with people's heads. Or, if the comany and share holders believe he's dead he could be doing it for some business reasons.[/b]
5)[u]Why is Vickers being Weyland's daughter kept a secret?[/u]
[b]Vickers being Weyland's daughter is kept secret from the audience. Never in the film does it suggest that this fact is kept from the crew. She has a different last name but that doesn't mean that the last name was made up. Maybe a married name or she kept her mother's last name.[/b]
6)[u]Why does Vickers even go on the mission when it's against her best intrest in regards to taking over Weyland Industries? It's not in her best intrest if other "sharks" are on earth plotting to take over the company while she's on the mission.[/u]
[b]For one Weyland is not dead so the company is still his. Also, Vickers obviously has daddy issues. Her father prefers a replicant to her. Her father is dying. She expresses that in her opinion the mission is a joke and will not be successful therefore she believes her father is going to die on the mission. She looks at the mission as her last chance to redeem herself or win her father's love away from David.[/b]
7)[u]Why does Weyland take the voyage instead of sending a probe and funding further medical research?[/u]
[b]What medical research is going to uncover immortality?[/b]
8)[u]Why does Weyland think he can appreciate or understand immortality or the Engineers reasoning and capabilities when he himself states that his creatioin, David, cannot appreciate the immortality he has been given because he has no soul?[/u]
[b]Again, he's an eccentric, multi-quadrillionaire. He created another lifeform. He also obviously thinks he is on equal footing with the gods or Engineers. He is incredibly self rightious. And, unlike David, he has a soul.[/b]
9)[u]Why does the crew rush into the temple instead of waiting for the pups to finish mapping?[/u]
[b]They never go into any area of the pyramid that has not been mapped.[/b]
10)[u]Why would the crew remove their helmets when they admit that,
though breathable, it could still be dangerous?[/u]
[b]Once they find out it's breathable they never say anything about a chance of it still being dangerous. In fact, someone states that the air is, in fact, cleaner than earth's air.[/b]
11)[u]Why does David shine a flashlight at a hologram?[/u]
[b]He's in a very dark place and has a flashlight in his hand. When most people are in the dark and hear or see something moving they usually will shine said flashlight in that direction.[/b]
12)[u]How does Fifield and Milburn get lost when Fifield is in charge of the pups?[/u]
[b]The pup readout was loading to the display on the ship, Fifield had a piece of the equipment that showed them the readout however when he and Millburn decided to leave rather near their point of entry he had to leave the equipment with the crew who were staying so they could continue to find their way. Fifield and Millburn being men both think they can find their own way and don't bother contacting Janek for directions. Then the storm hits knocking out contact.[/b]
13)[u]Why are geologist Fifield and biologist Millburn not interested in the uber-important descoveries that the team make in the pyramid?[/u]
[b]It's possible that they are too frightened to care about their careers at that point. Or better yet they are interested but are smart enough to hang back until the pyramid is found to be safe and without threat.[/b]
14)[u]Why is Millburn stupid enough to try to pet the hammerpeede?[/u]
[b]Perhaps his inquisitive, biologist nature that was talked about being absent in question #36 has finally got the better of him. Also, Fifield had just showed him that he had marajuana in his resperator. This could explain why Fifield is super paranoid as well as why Millburn wants to pet the hammerpeede. Fifield is paranoid because he's stoned and Millburn is trying to show off in order to impress Fifield so he'll share the marajuana.[/b]
15)[u]How is human dna and engineer dna a match yet there are differences between them?[/u]
16)[u]Why doesn't the crew ask David to translate Engineer writing when they find out there's a contagion loose?[/u]
[b]When they find out Holloway's infected is the first sign of a contagion. At this point they are in the pyramid and find Millburn's body and see that Fifield is missing. They also see the hammerpeede scuttle off which scares them as well. The sh*t has hit the fan at this point.They don't think about or have time to ask David to translate anything as they are trying to hurry
and get to the Prometheus to help Holloway. Besides, David is off on his own mission at the orrey in the Juggernaut.[/b]
17)[u]Why does Janek go to have sex with Vickers?[/u]
[b]Seriously??? All joking aside, Janek is the captain of the ship. He's not responsible for anything scientific which is what the mapping of the pyramid is. Also, at this point he has told Fifield and Millburn to hunker down and not bugger each other and all is quiet. Finally, at this point, there has been no threat. Just what he believes to be glitches with the pups.[/b]
18)[u]Why does nobody get angry at Janek for dereliction of duty?[/u]
[b]See above answer.[/b]
19)[u]Why does David infect Holloway for no reason?[/u]
[b]Before David infects Holloway he has a conversation with Weyland who is in cryo. When David leaves he comes upon Vickers lurking in the corridors. She askes David what Weyland said. "He said to try harder" he tells her. Weyland wants to find out what the "black goo" is capable of without being the guinea pig. Could it make him immortal? Could it make him morph into an alien? Could it give him the runs? He tells David to infect someone. David picks the person he likes the least of the crew. [/b]
20)[u]Why does infected Holloway act ok and return to the temple putting his girlfriend and crew in danger?[/u]
[b]Holloway has no idea he's infected. He dosn't know what David did. All that happened before they left for the pyramid was what he saw in his eye in the mirror. He could have been thinking he was seeing things due to cryo or space travel or whatever. He didn't display any pain until they were in the ampule room and at that point he asked Shaw if what was going on was bad.[/b]
21)[u]How does David know what 3 months pregnant looks like in terms of an alien?[/u]
[b]David tells Shaw she's 3 months pregnant BEFORE he tells her it's not human. He's telling her she's 3 months pregnant in terms of the size of a human fetus at 3 months. He knows they haven't been there for 3 months and that the alien fetus couldn't be that old as they hadn't been there 3 months.[/b]
22)[u]Why does David put Shaw to sleep when she asks him to take the alien fetus out?[/u]
[b]First, putting Shaw to sleep and in cryo is the most rational actions he could take as the med-pod only works on males and they don't have the personel to do the procedure.[/b]
23)[u]Why does Shaw not mention David's behavior to anyone after the c-section?[/u]
[b]Because his behavior was totally rational.[/b]
24)[u]Why is nobody, especially David,curious about what happened to Shaw and her baby after the c-section?[/u]
[b]David trumped Shaw's pregnancy with the surviving Engineer. After he was found, anything else was secondary - which includes Shaw's baby. And David was the only one who SAW the fetus. I doubt he said much, of if he did, he was deliberately vague. Weyland's only concern was meeting his "maker", and since Shaw was obviously alive and coherent, why would Weyland even care? He was on borrowed time, only days to live - if that. He's not going to give a crap about what Shaw was up to.[/b]
25)[u]Why does Janek assume that LV-233 is an "experimental weapons depot" located far away from the Engineer's home world?[/u]
[b]Janek explains this himself to Shaw in the film.[/b]
26)[u]If LV-233 is in fact an "experimental weapons depot" why would the Engineers give humans a map to it?[/u]
27)[u]Why is the ships control system started by a flute and controlled with buttons instead of being contolled by a flute OR buttons exclusively?[/u]
[b]Do cars start up when you push the gas pedal or stereo buttons? No. They start with keys. The flute is the key the Engineers chose.[/b]
28)[u]Why does the awakened Engineer attack instead of finding out what's going on?[/u]
[b]He has just been awakened early from a long sleep by inferior beings who he and his kind created and now want to destroy. These inferior beings have somehow found them and the rest of his beings on the ship are dead. He sees them somewhat of a threat. He has no idea what they know or what they're capable of. Not physically, he knows he can handle them physically. He's worried about what they know about the Juggernauts on the planet and their plan to destroy mankind.[/b]
29)[u]Why do Janek's co-pilots offer up their lives so readily?[/u]
[b]First ands foremost the fact that the lifeboat can only sustain life for 2 years means they are going to die before anyone can rescue them anyway. Also, Janek seems to be a boss that they definitely look up to and they obviously respect him to the utmost. Plus, how often do you get a chance to save the entire planet instead of running like a coward?[/b]
30)[u]Why doesn't Vickers run sideways to avoid crash?[/u]
31)[u]Why does the Juggernaut fall straight down during the crash instead of at an angle?[/u]
32)[u]How does a rock hold the crashing Juggernaut up, saving Shaw's life?[/u]
[b]If you look you can see that the part of the Juggernaut that lands where Shaw is is sloped inward which means the part of the ship that hit the rock was also lower to the ground when the ship hits. If the ship is sitting flat on flat ground that part of the ship would not be touching the ground.[/b]
33)[u]Why does the Engineer go after Shaw with bare hands when there are more Juggernauts?[/u]
[b]See question #28.[/b]
34)[u]How does Shaw's baby grow so big in a confined area with no food source?[/u]
[b]The trilobite fetus grew at an alarming rate while inside with what would seem to be little nutrition from Shaw as from the time she had intercourse and was impregnated to the time of the c-section she had not eaten anything. The trilobite just continues this trend after the c-section. Or perhaps the trilobite ate some of the crew members we didn't see much of.[/b]
35)[u]Why does Shaw head for the Engineer's home when she knows they want to destroy humans?[/u]
[b]To get answers. She states this at the end of the film. She doesn't care the cost. In her mind she will get answers from the Engineers or die and meet her maker and get answers that way.[/b]
36)[u]How did Shaw manage to acomplish all the feats of strength and daring after a very painful c-section?[/u]
[b]Shaw gives herself painkilling shots during the c-section as well as after. The combination of future surgical tools and techniques, the ability of future drugs to kill pain as well as good ol' adrenaline could have easily helped her along.[/b]
37)[u]How did the Trilobite survive the sterilization process?[/u]
[b]The Trilobite does have some human DNA and perhaps the Pauling Med-pod's sterilization process is not calibrated for human/alien hybrid parasite trilobite.[/b]
38)[u]Why is the Prometheus no equipped with weapons to blow the Juggernaut up instead of having to fly into it?[/u]
[b]Scientific expedition. Not an attack ship.[/b]
[IMG]http://i1161.photobucket.com/albums/q507/Engineering211/sig2.jpg[/IMG]
