Forum Topic

craigamore
MemberOvomorphAug-13-2012 2:35 PMRecently Snorkelbottom, myself and several others have been having a rather vigorous debate about the canon status of AVP and whether or not Charles Bishop Weyland fits in with a timeline that now has Peter Weyland establishing the company.
I could go into ridiculous detail about both sides of this debate, but that would not do justice to either my side of the debate or Snorkelbottoms, so....here is the link to Snork's thread.......[url=http://www.prometheus-movie.com/community/forums/topic/9360]The FINAL Canon Debate[/url].........and I suggest you read as much of it as you can to fully appreciate both sides.
Either:
- A - As Snork contends: AVP is canon and Peter is so vain as to completely eliminate the founder of his company from its official corporate history, despite what the rest of world would already know considering Peter's Weyland Corp. is the largest of any kind in human history.
OR
- B - As I contend: Prometheus establishes a semi-reboot to the franchise that rejects the AVP's and their history, re-establishing the history of Weyland Corp. with Peter as the sole founder whose parents are left nameless on the timeline as they are little more than his parents, not famous or of note in any way other than that they gave Peter life....i.e....The franchise begins with Prometheus and chronologically continues through Alien and its sequels.
We have gone back and forth so much that I believe we have reached an impass in which we must turn this over to the people.
Please vote members and tell tell us where you stand....
31 Replies
Add A Reply