Alien: Earth and Alien: Romulus sequel news

HELP ME MAKE SENSE OF PROMETHEUS!!!!(SPOILERS)

1671 Views26 Replies
Forum Topic

Secure that shit Hudson!

MemberOvomorphJune 08, 2012
After seeing Prometheus I am highly disapointed. I am a huge fan of the Alien saga. There are wayyy too many pit falls and condradictions and sadly I feel that Ridley only came back for a pay check.I feel he spent more time trying to dissociate Alien from the film when he should of been associating it. The last minute apperance of that reptile like creature seemed to be a far cry attempt to draw fans of Alien into seeing Prometheus 2. I also think the Blame lies with Damon Lindelof who was the executive producer and writer.Lindelof is also responsible for LOST which in all honesty was a Train wreck of an ending.So why let him near such a beloved saga? [b]Firstly . . . David . . [/b] David is a robot,one of the 3 codes of robotics is that they cannot hurt human beings in anyway.the promotional videos with David in them for the film(http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3oU-yT4nfkY&feature=fvwrel) clearly show David saying that he is aware of human emotions just cannot feel them. surely the act of deliberatedly infecting someone defies the laws of robotics that are enforced in the promotional videos. Why does david even bother infecting charlie(shaws boyfriend). What is the reasoning? even this defies the laws of robotics as maliciousness and deviousness are human feelings. I considered the fact that perhaps it would be to see if charlie became immortal testing it out before applying the method to peter weyland but even this defies the laws. [b]Secondaly . . Black Goo[/b] If the black Goo is a biological weapon then why did the enginner at the very start of the film deliberatedly drink the black goo?.And also if the goo had the effect on the enginner and Human and enginner DNA are supposedly Identical then why didnt the humans disintegrate and decompose like the enginner? Where did the black Goo even come from?? Where did the reptile creatures in the tomb chamber come from?? The movie implys that the tomb was a military base and the engineers devolped the black goo.But why?It is also implyed it was developed to destroy the humans.again . . . why? Why would the enginners create human life to destroy them?Is it simply just because they can ? or like David suggests in the film perhaps humans were becoming too far evolved and threatened to over power the enginners . . . but even this does not make sense as the film at the begininng states that if the engineers are real then evolution cannot be . . [b]Finally . . . Final Alien creature[/b] The creature arises as a result of the octopus creature overpowering the enginner. why does it resemble an octopus ? and was it a result of the maggots in the black Goo? Is the Black Goo like a DNA transcribing Mechanism that isolates the worst parts of the DNA and exploits it into vile creatures? The fact that the full grown alien emerged from the enginner could it be a possibilty that the enginners are only shells for the aliens the whole time,Like Cacoons.and the black Goo acts as a catalyst to release the alien? Why does the alien look reptillian and not like our traditional alien?? the only answer I can assume is evolution of the species . . . the same evolution thats disproved by the crew by finding the enginners!! Unfortunately Prometheus is too vague a film for any interpatation to be correct.I completely agree with writing that leaves the audience to decide the faith of a story but not when key elements are neglected and random occurence events are incorporated to simply attempt to be creative story writing. In conclusion the film is insulting to the Alien saga in my opinion and its attempt at complex story telling yet again left audiences LOST
User Avatar
I Like to eats y'all with my little mouth too
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
TBH 'secure that shit' I think you just need to chill out and grow up a little. It's not an 'Alien' movie, get over it. Most of the answers to your questions and have been given already. TY to the guy who suggested the engineer who sacrificed himself at the start was 'Prometheus' I so buy that. But then 'secure that shit', you make a ridiculous comment supported by a clip from youtube which says it disproves what is obviously a totally plausible explanation and leaves me wondering if you watched the clip yourself. The film is clearly made to make you think and you don't like that. Maybe stick to comedies. I was hungry for answers when I left the theatre and everyone is entitled to an opinion, there are plenty of reasons not to love this film and I would accept you complaining for any of them with exception to the fact that you're lazy and want to be spoon fed simple narrative.
User Avatar
StarphishPrime
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
you guys are all stupid. And being the arch-nerd that I am, I'm tired of reading your stupid answers. An analysis of Prometheus- from beginning to end. ****SPOILERS**** 1. Why does the engineer in the beginning commit suicide to begin human life? The first thing to notice is how –ritualistic- his suicide was. Apart from the jedi robe and the goo being in a ceremonial container, later in the movie several things hint at the culture of the engineers- like the room with the giant human face monument and the murals reminiscent of those found in the Sistine Chapel, and the part where they awaken the surviving engineer himself, and he places a hand upon the head of the android David, before using it to kill his creator in turn. So this infers a society focusing on the transformation of death and rebirth, which is a very prominent concept in many western and eastern religions on earth. 2. Why is everyone on this expedition a complete dumbass? Weak writing; poor focus on the allocation of resources into making the movie; perhaps purposeful appeal to stupid audiences? I myself found it strange that a group of interstellar scientists are stupid enough to contaminate the interior of the alien craft by removing their helmets (the melting murals). And how the geologist and biologist become lost after their freak-out, when they are being monitored by the ship’s crew (complete with holographic display of their exact location) the entire time. They seem to be easily spooked by harmless holograms, but immediately wanna shove their faces into the first phallic alien they come upon, while knowing nothing about it. The captain of this expensive endeavor is a drunk, and is more pre-occupied with having sex than watching the two ass-hats who got lost in the ruin. Not to mention that the best thing to do when a circular spaceship is rolling after you is to run sideways. 3. Why do all the cave paintings / clues point to a star formation that turns out to be a military facility? This is a bit obscure, and could very well be the result of poor writing. However I have an idea. If you notice, there seems to be a lot of references to God in this movie. *hint hint* and how the engineers created us *hint hint* AND how these particular engineers seemed to be setting a course to earth precisely 2000 years ago. To apparently destroy it? What biblical event is proposed to have happened 2000 years ago? Well, Jesus being crucified by the Romans of course. I myself am not religious (im actually an atheist) and I’m not drawing this conclusion from any feverish visions. But it seems hilariously and obviously hinted that Jesus was an alien, an engineer emissary saying “we created you, worship us.” What’s a likely way to piss off any civilization? Crucify their emissary, thus they were preparing to destroy us. Perhaps this facility was simply assigned to monitor planet earth in case shit got fucked up, perhaps earth was part of the facility’s experiments involving the black goo (queue the beginning of the movie). But one thing is for sure, this place is fucked up. 4. Why did David contaminate Charlie? I honestly don’t know why everyone kept asking this. It’s more obvious than any other subtlety in the movie. If you notice, unless you are a complete asshole, David tries being courteous and nice to everyone for most of the film- and what he gets back are jibes and insults and references to how sub-human he is, and how GREAT –real- humans are. Well unless you think shit tastes like candy, I’d wager you’d get tired of it too. So David at a key moment in the film, decides to play god and put humanity in its place a little. He wasn’t instructed to do this, nor does he have some sort of superfluous agenda to the superficial plots in the film, he just got pissed off- and Charlie was being a colossal douche. What better candidate to see what the black goo does?! Besides this, he obviously is responsible for taking care of Weyland, and considering Weylands intentions, part of that job entails finding out what the fuck sort of aliens the engineers are, what the fuck does the black goo do, and what kind of shit are they all getting into? 5. The black goo, how does it work? Magnets! But no… all it appears to be is a high-tech mutagen, and there’s nothing saying that the goo in the ceremonial container in the beginning of the movie is the same as the stuff that appears to be weaponized in the alien bomber spaceship. Maybe there’s different goo that does different things? Maybe the goo reacts differently with engineers than it does with human beings, considering it turned the geologist into a hulking zombie mutant contortionist, and it turned the engineer in the beginning into a metaphorical tree of life. The weaponized goo seems to just mutate the fuck out of whatever organic thing it touches, which would be a fantastic weapon because of all the obvious chaos this would cause on a planetary scale. But how does it relate to the xenomorphs, and why all the absurd progression from goo to zombie to alien fetus to giant alien starfish to xenomorph? Well if you remember me illuminating some of the clues as to the culture of the engineers, you may find it beyond coincidental that they kept a lot of the goo containing vases in what is an obviously very ceremonial and perhaps religious chamber. ALSO if you were paying attention to the movie, one of the central murals in that chamber, is of a fucking giant alien queen. We are dealing with a civilization obsessed with the creation of life, death and resurrection- very much like the nature of the xenomorphs themselves. Perhaps the xenomorphs are some culmination between technology and idolatry. It’s not that xenomorphs require some dude to get contaminated and fuck a chic before he turns into a zombie to get the giant face-hugger to impregnate something else- because that’s not a very efficient way to get the desired result. Its more that no matter the origins and nature of contamination induced by the weapon (the goo), it all leads to one conclusion- as shown in the mural with all the mutating shit slowly becoming the alien queen in the center. But wait, what the fuck is the giant face-hugger? In the lore its actually called a “trilobite” and differs blatantly from the beloved facehuggers we all know from our youth. Also you will notice the weird non-traditional alien that pops out of the engineer. Well, if you remember every baby xenomorph from Christmas past, they were all tiny clumsy things. This one was man-sized when it was born, and fairly well developed (also very feminine in its movements). In the lore there are more than just queen aliens, there is also what’s called an Empress (I am not making this up, go play the games). The massive trilobite is like a buffed up version of the facehugger, and this “Empress” is like a buffed up version of a xenomorph queen. Savy? But there’s more to this, in the movie it is said at one point that the giant dome is actually hollow. But its soon revealed that the expedition isn’t spending time in some alien pyramid, they are in a ship- a ship which isn’t in the dome- it’s in some gigantic hangar beneath the flatland. So what the fuck is the purpose of the dome? If you think back to alien 2, the xenomorphs chose the huge powerplant for their hive- not the colonial compound. Why would engineers need a giant hollow dome on a planet they just happen to be creating a religious bio-superweapon that inevitably forms into xenomorph aliens that like building hives in grand open spaces? Hmmmm, maybe because… wait I think I said it already.
User Avatar
Custodian
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
nah, I think you're all REACHING on this. wait, my preciouses, be patient - 10/11/12 is only months away now. :)
2013 sci-fi horror novels 'Custodian' and 'Tandem' available from Amazon, B&N, iTunes etc...
User Avatar
lazygreatdane
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
I had a different interpretation. At the beginning when the Engineer was left standing at the water fall which is clearly the falls in Africa on Earth. The Engineer left behind, drank the black goo and then fell over the falls into the water. This Engineer died when falling over the falls. And then the cut scene with DNA replicating was shown to create a new species. This implied that out of the Engineer who drank the black goo propagated a new species which is human. The Engineer's DNA was mixed with Earths fish/plants etc which created man's DNA. So we are part Engineer and part Human. A total new species created by the black goo out of the Engineer. In the same way, the Engineer created a new species out of the Octopus looking creature which sprang forth the Alien. My thoughts then is this: why did the Engineers leave the other Engineer on Earth and fly away in their space ship to leave this Engineer behind? Was he dooped into drinking the black goo thinking it was something else he was drinking? Did he want to create a new human species and knew this would be the price he would pay as his friends sailed away-death? Was this an Abraham moment when he would be the father of a new generation? If so, were the other Engineers who flew away watching the human's for ages during their evolution and found them to be too warrior like? Thus my conclusion or opinion: they decided to create a bio weapon which was an Alien to destroy man kind? Much in the same way God attempted to wipe out man for being evil doers in the Old Testament when he destroyed Sodom and Gomorah. And also when he sent a flood to destroy man again when Noah was on the Earth. The same thing is going on here. The Engineer wants to destroy his creation because it is too evil for him to even handle.
User Avatar
Indy John
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
It seems to me we are giving humans too much credit for being a threat to Engineers. It inflated my ego that the human race could be seen as a serious threat to creatures who have been space travellng for millions of years(exaggerating a bit here). David and even Weyland seemed to be in awe of the Engineer's world. Clearly the Sactifical Engineer seemed to be doing what he wanted to do..oit made sense to him. It would be a cruel joke if he was tricked by others to drink the goo because it was good for him! If as you say he knew he was creating life would any posters here trade their life for that opportunity? Maybe if it involved a new Lamborghini.
Be choicelessly aware as you move through life
User Avatar
zzplural
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile
There has to be more to it than that. If he simply wanted to create new life, he could have taken a blood sample and mixed it with the black goo. No, there's a spiritual element to this as well. I suspect that he was making a sacrifice to the God(s) in the same way that humans did for thousands of years. A modern human would not relish this prospect, but in ancient times, being chosen as a sacrifice could be an honour, with a year of lavish living before the anointed time.
The most terrifying fact about the universe is not that it is hostile but that it is indifferent

Join the discussion!



Recently Active Forums
Alien: Earth Series
Alien: Earth SeriesDiscuss the Alien FX TV series here!
Alien: Covenant
Alien: CovenantDiscuss the Prometheus Sequel, Alien: Covenant
Prometheus Fan Art
Prometheus Fan ArtArtwork & Fiction From the Fans
Alien
AlienDiscuss all things Alien here
New Forum Topics
Hot Forum Topics
Highest Forum Ranks Unlocked
Svanya
Svanya » Praetorian
89% To Next Rank
ninXeno426
ninXeno426 » Praetorian
62% To Next Rank
Thoughts_Dreams
Thoughts_Dreams » Neomorph
88% To Next Rank
Neomorph
Neomorph » Chestburster
94% To Next Rank
cuponator3000
cuponator3000 » Chestburster
84% To Next Rank
Latest Media
Community Stats
This Alien Movie Universe community is part of the Scified network. Scified hosts a network of online fan-site communities containing 406,476 posts by 48,459 members (16 are online now). The Alien: Earth Series Forum is the most recently active forum. The latest Forum topic added was: Alien Earth parallels
VIPWhat are VIP?AdminModeratorSpecial TitleMember
Join the discussion!
Please sign in to access your profile features!
(Signing in also removes ads!)



Forgot Password?
Scified Website LogoYour sci-fi community, old-school & modern
Hosted Fansites
AlienFansite
GodzillaFansite
PredatorFansite
Main Menu
Community
Sci-Fi Movies
Help & Info
+

Sign In to contribute!