No to another AVP sequel, but yes to an AVP origin movie?

Yeah it's a great idea but here's the kicker. The general public in the United States will not go see an AVP movie with no human characters in it. It just won't appeal to the regular moviegoer just to the hardcore fans and the studio, 20th Century Fox in this instance, won't spend money on this knowing the general public will not go. They need to make money off this movie and they won't make enough profit off of it, maybe none at all, with just the hardcore fan base. It would do a lot better in the foreign market and as great as that is they still want the movie to be a success domestically and it wouldn't.

I mentioned this on the thread I believe kanes new face got the realisation from. I don't want a movie like avp again but agree something that show cases the first confrontation between the 2 species. something like, a hunt takes place in space, same timeline-ish as alien. the predators r hunting a human ship bound for a planet to terraform, unaware of a xeno nest on the planet. the humans land and after a bit some go missing. the predators scan the planet from orbit, though looking only for humans completely miss any detection of the xeno. when the hunter is sent to the planet only a handful of humans r left and the predator has to use all his skills to avoid becoming prey to the xeno himself. not interested in the predator teaming up with the humans, this becomes a battle for him to survive as much as the humans as he has never encountered the xeno before so is unprepared

would love to see a scene where the predator is cloaked, moving silently toward his prey. we see the heat vision of the lone person who hears something. the predator assumes it is himself the human detects. the predator is 10 feet away and we see his heat vision. clear as day the human stands. all of a sudden the human is hoisted into the air by some unseen force. we see, in the heat vision, an impact on the humans skull and then the human is gone, vanishing through an air duct or something. the predator stands, bewildered and confused and now goes to investigate

I would love the OP plot, but we don't live in a world where that could be made financially viable as stated above. 

However, the original AvP novel would not be far from the other storylines presented here and I would support that movie being made. Weyland-Yutani seeds an agriculture/ animal husbandry type colony with eggs to infect the populace and finally grow their very own xenomorph colony. Predators show up for "normal" hunting excursion. Outbreak happens and Preds are killing everyone (colonials and colonial marines) and everything (xenos) just to survive.

They do end up working with main character, Mahiko Naguchi, at the end but from the human perspective I found it quite terrifying throughout.

@MrGoodkat      That sounds pretty fucking cool

I didn't realize this thread actually came into being. When I tried to create it originally I was getting an error. But since it's here, this was the initial idea I had for an opening to such a movie. Keep in mind, I punched it out pretty quickly and it really only should cover about the first 20 minutes of this movie that we'll never see...

The movie would open with some sort of fire fight in space between a small Predator craft and some other alien species with advanced tech. The Predator craft would take a critical hit and be sent plummeting towards a nearby planet.

At the crash we see two predators. One is unscathed and the other has some decent injuries. The the injured predator remains on board the crashed ship while the other exits to survey the planet. Shortly after, the injured predator witnesses his shipmate taken off-guard by several snarling black creatures. Within moments screams and howls of pain can be heard. By the time the injured predator collects itself to aid his shipmate, he exits the ship only to find a trail of neon blood leading off to a cave at the base of a cliff.

The predator follows the trail into the cave, wandering into the darkness. More commotion is heard from within the cave. The cries of a predator can be heard along with the sound of it's weapon discharging several times and some very high pitched squeals/screams. It is then that the injured predator stops dead in it's tracks as it notices the walls around it begin moving. Now leaving it's shipmate behind to some unknown fate it struggles to escape the walls as they close in.

Out of the cave now, the predator struggles to escape as it knows the walls of the cave haven't stopped their pursuit. Racing back towards the ship, grunting in pain. It hasn't finished treating it's injuries from the crash. Every stride is painful. It pulls a device from it's leg and throws it a few feet ahead as a hanging vine becomes a mechanism of escape.

The predator swings over the device it threw and into the brush ahead. It does not stop running as an explosion is heard behind. Moving now much more slowly. It's injuries have worsened. It reluctantly slows and begins to fall only to roll under a large bolder jutting partially out of the ground. It lays quiet, waiting. There is nothing but silence. The pursuers do not seem to have followed this far. The predator drifts into darkness.

Waking now face in the dirt. It is night. The predator pulls itself up, unclear of how long it has been unconscious. It checks the terminal on it's forearm which is now shooting sparks. It was destroyed. The predator begins limping with purpose. It's destination soon becomes clear. The lights of the fallen craft shine through the trees. The predator makes it's way into what remains of the cockpit. It reaches into a side compartment and pulls out a what appears to be a rolled up tool set. It begins performing surgery on itself. First it's outter thigh, then it's ribs. Completing the final steps of the procedure now, it's wounds seems to have almost vanished. It is then that something on the main control panel catches the predators eye.

The control panels are all but destroyed. It looks as if magma had been spattered across them. This damage wasn't present when he and the other had sent out the distress signal which now appears to no longer be broadcasting. Something had happened in the ship while the predator was out in search of the other. It became clear all too quickly. Without the ability to broadcast a signal from the cockpit, the predator would need to use it's terminal which was no longer functioning. It's only option would be to find the other predator.

The predator pushes against the back of the pilot seat. The seat of the chair opens, revealing several components of armor and a mask. After fitting these to itself, the predator exits the ship and begins walking cautiously in the direction of the cave it had narrowly escaped from.......

^^^^ more, need to know what happened to his ship

I think the only direction they could take at this point with AvP is Aliens + Predators + marines in space.

id like that but for me id like it to be the first time the predators encounter the xeno. say they are hunting the marines as the ultimate human hunt. the marines have been sent in to clear a nest and the predator follows them, unaware of what hes walking into

They first encountered Aliens thousands of years ago.

After 30+ years everyone knows what Aliens and Predators are now. An origin story is a bit redundant at this point.

that's no reason it cant be done. look at the dark knight trilogy, or what ridley is doing with his prequel trilogy. things can go in different directions than what has already been done.

A stranded Predator turning from hunter to hunted could work. But origin stories can get very tiresome, particularly when the audience is very familiar with the content.

Nolan got away with an origin story in Batman Begins - because we'd never seen it before outside comics.  In the Burton films, Bruce Wayne is already Batman before the film begins.

I was talking about the villains. the joker and 2 face more specifically. already done in previous movies yet Nolan did them completely differently. iv yet to see somewhere say that this cant be done in the avp universe. oh sorry, uv said it cant happen so I suppose that's it then

It could happen and Christopher Nolan is the man!

his trilogy was awesome. and absolutely no reason that concept cant be used in the avp universe

I didn't say it can't be done; only that it doesn't sound terribly interesting, especially considering a much bigger audience is crying out for AvPvUSCM.

maybe not to u but others may find it a good way to save the crossover. in comics and books it is awesome but onscreen it bombed. a darker more origins themed movie could be just what it needs. and I think the AvPvUSCM would be a brilliant way to go. it brings the 3 species together though not in the way some might expect. the USCM's have been sent in to clear a nest/ samples to allow for terraforming though they have been detected by a far off predator hunting clan ship which has now followed them. the marines land followed by the predators who have no idea what else is down there, maybe? like I say theres no reason this couldn't be the first encounter between pred and xeno even though avp and predator 2 has shown it isn't. this clan may not have come across the xeno? the director may do a 'Nolan' and go another path

They bombed critically.  They did pretty well in terms of box office.

yea that's bums on seats. u have 2 of the biggest franchises coming together, ofcourse it was going to make money. but in general terms of what fans thought, IT BOMBED

@ali81 Yep I agree, if something works than try to use the same method. They could definitely do what the great Christopher Nolan did for Batman, The Dark Knight Trilogy are my favorite movies ever, and apply it to AVP!