Alien: Earth and Alien: Romulus sequel news

Why the prejudice against xenomorphs?

Lemonade

MemberOvomorphMarch 27, 20144196 Views35 Replies

Get ready for a SUPER, SUPER long post.

Are these the same fans that have always been around? Am I the only fan that wants to see the xenomorphs in a good movie for a change(or since 1986, at least)? They are a cool shape and their full potential hasn't been utilized. Just because Prometheus 2 is going to be MORE alien-y doesn't mean it's going to be a full on xenomorph movie. Ridley Scott is obviously not going to direct something he doesn't believe in or doesn't want to. Prometheus was 90% new, 10% Alien stuff, and I feel by "more alien-y" they mean it will be 70% new and 30% alien stuff. They HAVE to have the alien stuff. Where is the conflict going to come from? No one is going to watch a movie where Shaw is talking to the engineers while David translates for two hours. This is a TENTPOLE movie with a big budget, there's just no way. And I personally don't want to see two "factions"(cute) of engineers brawling with each other, or shooting lasers, or any other lame Star Trek-esque shit. I don't want my Ridley Scott sci-fi to be Star Trekky, and optimistic, and sleak. I want it MAJESTIC and DARK and BEAUTIFUL, with a real sense of DANGER and DEEP THEMATIC elements.

I always wanted my beloved xenomorphs to be in a good-looking, modern, good movie. Alien and Aliens are the only good ones, but they're old. Forget the cartoons that were A3 and A4, and the crossover abominations. This creature isn't PLAYED OUT, it is simply MISHANDLED AND ABUSED. The alien should never be the focus of a good alien movie, it should instead be INCIDENTAL. 

Yes, we’ve had “seven” movies with xenomorphs in them, but how many of them have been good? Most people would say the first two. I think the xenomorphs are deserving of a good movie. They are my favorite movie monster, and it has always been my fantasy that the Alien franchise would get the “Blade Runner”, or “Batman Begins”, treatment. Something deep and serious with A-list talent in front of and behind the camera. Prometheus was kind of that. Kind of. I just know I wanted to see the Giger beast in that beautiful lighting. Because let’s be honest, Prometheus was gorgeous. My fandom covers Alien, Aliens, and Prometheus, by the way.

And nobody tells Ridley Scott what to do. Nobody’s going to force him to do an aliens-on-the-attack movie. Please do remember, it was 20th CENTURY FOX that rejected Alien: Engineers. Yes, the studio said remove the aliens. More specifically, I’m guessing it was Tom Rothman.

Hell, who knows what they even mean by more “Alien-y”. Maybe they just mean more heavy on the scares but without the traditional xenomorph. The point is, I’m beyond frustrated people assume we either have to take one or the other. That we either HAVE to have: A) A deep movie with just the engineers or B) A straight up monster movie without the engineers.

Are we forgetting who the writers are? Jack Paglen of Transcendence and Michael Green of uh, oh I don’t know, BLADE RUNNER 2? These guys write think-piece sci-fi. I don’t think they have it in them to write simple stories. I wager a guess that Paglen’s draft was pure sci-fi, but Michael Green talked some sense into Ridley and Fox. Like, if you’re going to make a big budget sci-fi movie, you’re going to HAVE to have action set pieces. It is a tentpole after all. People are not going to just watch Shaw ask the Engineers questions while David translates for two hours(Okay, I would). Has anyone ever thought that the filmmakers figured out a way to incorporate the aliens and the engineers in an organic way that makes sense to the story? Strange concept, I know…

Anyway, again, I’ve always wanted a big, deep Alien prequel where the movie wasn’t about the aliens, but the aliens were in it. Prometheus was ALMOST that, and it is ALMOST a perfect movie to me, but I just wanted around 10 minutes of facehuggers and xenomorphs. Then my score would go from 9.5/10 to 10/10.

Anyway, I hope Prometheus 2 intellectually engages me like Prometheus(and Inception, I’m still wrestling with both of those movies) but on that same token, I am a horror fan and would like to see my favorite designs(the Oscar-winning xenomorph design, and the facehuggers) do some damage. There is nothing wrong with that. Those designs deserve better than some low grade B movie. I haven’t seen a gorgeous shot of an Alien since ’86. Alien 3 is tainted by those damn mo-cap shots! A4 looks like a cartoon. Don’t have to explain the rest. Haha.

So in essence, intellectually engage me AND scare/gross me out. The engineers by themselves are gross and boring

User Avatar
BigDave
Group: Member
Rank: Deacon
View Profile

I have discussed this a number of times, and i feel the reason why in Alien the creature was more of a Horror element was because of the enclosed enviroment and the lack of military training and equipment the Nostromo crew had...

If they encounter the Organism in a more open space and was faced and out numbered by Armed and Trained Mercs etc then the Xeno would not be able to pick them off one by one.

The interesting thing from Alien was the Xeno had a agenda, it was a organism that had fear, it knew it could not go out in the open and it had to be stealthy, it was the only one of its kind on that ship and as the deleted scenes shown its Agenda was to procreate.

In Aliens the Xenos was clever they cut off the electric supply, they use the space above the ceiling to sneak upon the Marines.

Ridley had described the Xeno as being insect like before Cameron gave us the Bugs, likewise he also said the Space Jockey was a suit long before Prometheus to the dismay of those who view the Space Jockey as a Giant Elephantine Organism.

If the Xenos purpose is to procreate and this comes from Star Beast concept and ideas in that draft that Alien was based off, then Camerons idea of a Queen makes sense if these Organisms main use is to Procreate its kind, in which the Egg Morph scene makes more sense if its to produce a Queen.

Maybe the idea of how this Organism Procreates is not how Ridley intended to do so, if he made the Alien Sequel.... but not Ridley can use the ideas he had to be used with a new breed of Xeno.... or the Xeno's predessor and go that route of creating a new Horror that has Xeno connection but that behaves differently to the way the Xeno evolved on screen after Alien.

R.I.P Sox  01/01/2006 - 11/10/2017

User Avatar
Anunnaki50
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

I agree with Lemonade about the sci-fi part being dark and creepy with mystery. I just dont think Ridley would even think of doing a submarine type warfare in space like star trek becausee its not that at all. Engineers probably do battle like humans do except with biotech and engineering black goo to suit their needs. I want to see the Deacon rip head off and start doing the killing one by one and then when needed go back to where Shaw and David are.

The Anunnaki were on the earth in those days--and also afterward--when the sons of God went to the daughters of humans and had children by them. They were the heroes of old, mighty men of high reno

User Avatar
Anunnaki50
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

Honestly I love the creature too but dont make this an Alien-y movie in terms of the xenos just ET suspense and mystery with the Space Jockey race that what it was about anyway.

The Anunnaki were on the earth in those days--and also afterward--when the sons of God went to the daughters of humans and had children by them. They were the heroes of old, mighty men of high reno

User Avatar
brego
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

There are plenty of aspectes of the Xeno genus which we have yeat to see.  Growth wtages, resin creation, worker to Queen growth.... These areas Ridley could explore...

User Avatar
Lemonade
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

@Brego

Nah, that's not stuff I wanna see. Does anyone give a shit about how they create resin, or what they eat, etc? No.

I'm talking about stuff like Spaihts' David/facehugger scene.

User Avatar
Redant
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

I am very surprised that no one is thinking what is really possible now with 
special effects.

Look at the new work done on Transformers....a lot of that stuff looks incredible.

So don't anyone say what cannot be done. 

They could make a new Alien movie much better than the first no problem at all.

It could be very scary and dark. Put the right tools in the hands of the right artists and you can make anything! There is nothing that cannot be immagined!

User Avatar
BigDave
Group: Member
Rank: Deacon
View Profile

@Lemonade

 

I for one would love to see the connection to the Resin and Xeno, and Engineers Bio-Tech as there does seem to be some kind of link to how the Xeno produces the Resin to build hives and the look of the contruction of the Derelict and Jugernaught and Engineer Walls and corridors.. And there is a connection to the Engineers Space Jockey Suits and Preasure Suits and the Xeno Bio Tech Exo-Skeleton.

I would like more to find what genetic and manufacturing connection there is between the two, as opposed to be shown here is a Xeno Egg and wham... Xenos on the lose.  The only clue we need to Alien as far as the same kind of Xeno we see in Alien Franchise is simply how do the Eggs come about, once we see how they are made/evolved or laid etc etc, then we know the rest!

R.I.P Sox  01/01/2006 - 11/10/2017

User Avatar
brego
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

Well Lemonade, id definately like to see resin creation. Id also like to see growth stages, skin shedding etc etc. There are plenty of canon ideas which we have yet to see....
Another idea is the hierachy of the hive and what would happen where different hives meet. Does a Queen require fertilising? 

Also as we are looking at other worlds with probably a number of native species we could see a number of different Xenos... The possibilitie are endless, along of course finding out why or how in the first place the Xeno species came to be. Accident or by design.

 

User Avatar
BigDave
Group: Member
Rank: Deacon
View Profile

Yes Brego it would be interesting but then we would see movie that is well in essence another Alien movie...

I would actually hope they go a different route and uncover that the Engineers/Elders must have came across some Organism, or something else that they used to borrow and create there Bio Tech from and that the Xeno is one of many experiments created from dabling with what ever they found.

We could thus get a explanation and clues to how come the Engineers Bio-Tech and Xenos etc are related.

It does not even have to be a creature, it could be some kind of machine, or even some kind of Substance.... but i dont like that route because well as the movie did try and imply that this Goo was the basis for all things including the Xeno and us, i just think it has holes in it as far as to how come Mankind carried Engineer DNA and Traits and not Xeno and how come the Organisms and events in Prometheus carried Xeno Traits and DNA and not Engineers etc.

R.I.P Sox  01/01/2006 - 11/10/2017

User Avatar
BigDave
Group: Member
Rank: Deacon
View Profile

My idea was that these Engineers had used the Goo to seed worlds as we saw at the Start and that what we saw in the movies is there Goo breaks down their DNA and acts a a Evolutionary Accelerant to Hyrbid their DNA with basic Organic Life and that what occurs is it passes on Engineer DNA and kick starts Evolution and Engineers come back to carry out similar experments and thus mixing of DNA untill the creation of life we have now occuried.

But they did this on another World, but this world had somekind of under water Organism, like a Correl and some kind of Crustacean/Cephalopod Organism.  The Engineers may had done this my accident by a crashing of a ship that spilt a lot of the Goo the Sacrificial Engineers used.

What happend was this then lead to the Engineers on the ships DNA being broken down and mixed with the Organisms on the World and what we then got was a mix off Engineer DNA and best traits with the Crustacean/Cephalopod Organism DNA and Traits, Engineers and the Corral.

What we got was some new kinds of Organism, and Hybrid Engineers and the Engineers was like WOW look at that and then futher Engineered and borrowed from this accidental creation and what became of it was the Bio-Tech and then a whole host of other Organisms.

This Crustacean/Cephalopod Organism mixed with Engineer DNA produce something similar to the creature in the Fresco.

I had not yet gone into detail of exactly the process and stuff as was just flashing about a number of things connected to a idea as above for my draft.... but what stopped me in my tracks was how to explain the Engineer connection with creation of us and why and who created them etc.... This was a BIG QUESTION that i had trouble focusing on one answer lol

So i abandoned my draft and ideas as around that time it was confirmed Ridley and Fox had signed on someone who had worked on a draft allready.

 

R.I.P Sox  01/01/2006 - 11/10/2017

User Avatar
brego
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

Good ideas Big Dave. I think we could get the best of all new ideas plus the the Xeno stuff we wanna see and havn't yet seen. i think if the Vagina Squid and the Deacon had been more biomechanical and Xeno like and les fleshy and animalistic, we Alien fans would have been fullfilled and left eagerly wanting more... The only things I didnt like about Prometheus (other than some rather un scientific, professional behaviour by some of the Scientists) were the creature designs. In my mind it beggers belief that Giger was'nt offered, used and ultimately allowed to re disign his masterpeice. What we got was slightly too divergent from the masterful creatures that we love...

having said that Im totally looking forward to two!

 

User Avatar
BigDave
Group: Member
Rank: Deacon
View Profile

Giger had some input but then a few other Artists came on board and some of the concept work while they was going through Spaights draft before they got Lindeloff in and tonned down the Xeno elements.

Well the concept work was all very much Gigerish.... the Space Jockeys even looked more like the original.

I think they just wanted to dilute the Xeno DNA and this passed down to all aspects, mainly the Deacon as you see the Mural one was very Giger as it was Gigers work.  The end one was well less because it was supposed to be Human Hybrid after all...

I think the biggest disapointment as far as Giger feel and Xeno was Fifield... The Worms became larger and had that Alien look about them, they did not look like Worms no more.

Here is a Fifield that looked a lot like the Animatronic they was going to use, but then for some reason changed mind, so they just Toxic Avengered Fifield and then after they shot a CGI Alternative.

Here was Animatronic based on above..

And some other more Giger/Xeno Concept Fifield.

R.I.P Sox  01/01/2006 - 11/10/2017

User Avatar
brego
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

Yeah Id seen these designs, it was a shame that the CGI version of Fifield's return were a little animated looking, I understand why Ridley didnt use them in the final cut... I like the look of this version of Fifield, it is more Gigeresque... Pity it wasnt executed properly. As for the gigantic V-Squid, I hated it... I liked the body design of the Decon... But no tail... and I didn't like the mouth design... Loved the Engineers, despite the size issue, also the Silo interiors and other environments along with the Engineer's ship, all very Giger yet subtly updated...

Had a thought the other day that as the Xeno's seem to replicate their surrounding environment and host in some ways, perhaps the egg breeding senario is some kind of organic version of the Engineers vases, replicated genetically as some kind of dna copy, built to propegate. Maybe in the same vein as the Xeno's body details in some ways resembling the Engineers bio suits.... Just a thought. Maybe some kind of DNA memory....

User Avatar
BigDave
Group: Member
Rank: Deacon
View Profile

A lot of people was not keen on the Deacon and felt it was way watered down too.

But people seem to forget the process...

In Alien the Chest Busters loook different because they come from a Face Huger which we have to assume is more pure Xeno DNA, this Face Huger implants a Embryo into its host and this gestates for a period of time before we see the Chest Buster which is not quite the same design as the full Adult Xeno, its starts of smaller but grows a considerble amount.

Now some Organisms on Earth go through changes from Birth to Adult a Frog could be a example and also a Butterfly.

The Deacon at the end of Prometheus we have to remember again came from a Face Hugging event only the Face Huger was Larger, but we also have to remember this Face Huger was not pure Xeno DNA Face Huger....

Nope this came from Xeno DNA that had mutated and evolved what we must assume was a Early Stage Fetus, well at very least a infection of Xeno DNA at the Egg fertilization stage.

So what we have is a similar Organism to the Face Huger only one that looks a bit different but is not 100% Xeno Face Huger.... it is a Human DNA and Xeno DNA Hyrbid Face Huger, just as Hammerpedes seem to be Xeno DNA and Worm DNA Hybrid and Fifield a Humand DNA and Xeno DNA Hybrid that the original idea was (Spaights draft) and how the other concept works looked.

So now we get to the Trillobite being part Human and part Xeno, the resulting Chest Buster would be part Xeno/Human too, as far as traits go.

Maybe thats why it has a Placenta, and why it has no Tail and why it has more Human Hands and why its teeth are more Enamel and not Metalic like the Xenos.  We have to assume as a Human Baby is near fully formed compared to its Adult Stage (does not change much apart from pupety and size). Then the Deacon would not alter much but also grow like a Human and thus be 3.5X the size when its fully grown..

If so well i am sure as Babies and Puppies lose their cutness and get larger, then the Deacon would have more menacing features and also stand about 18ft tall.

R.I.P Sox  01/01/2006 - 11/10/2017

User Avatar
brego
Group: Member
Rank: Ovomorph
View Profile

yeah Big Dave, I get that and you are correct. The original burster was a fleshy, pink long head with a tail...  The body design of the Deacon was very adult Xeno like and I thought was a great expansion of the original... And I liked the metalic blueish hue, but the pointy head, lack of a tail and weird joke teeth mouth I hated... dont start me on the giant hugger... The size made it less shocking and dramatic. I think one of the reasons that the original hugger is so freakishly scary is that it overly strong for its size and was agile and quick.

Lets hope that as the Deacon grows it grows into a spikey, hard, biomechanical and beautiful creature, like the one we love.

Join the discussion!



Latest Media
Join the discussion!
Please sign in to access your profile features!
(Signing in also removes ads!)



Forgot Password?
Scified Website LogoYour sci-fi community, old-school & modern
Hosted Fansites
AlienFansite
PredatorFansite
AvPFansite
GodzillaFansite
Main Menu
Community
Help & Info
+

Sign In to contribute!